The PFA team of the year has been presented since the 1973/1974 season. Below is a list of Charlton Athletic players who have been voted for by the other players in their respective divisions that season.

1978/1979 – Mike Flanagan

1980/1981 – Derek Hales and Nicky Johns

1981/1982 – Paul Walsh

1985/1986 – Mark Aizlewood and Mark Reid

1993/1994 – Scott Minto

1995/1996 – Lee Bowyer and Richard Rufus

1997/1998 – John Robinson

1999/2000 – Andy Hunt, Mark Kinsella, Chris Powell, John Robinson and Richard Rufus

2009/2010 – Nicky Bailey and Fraser Richardson

2010/2011 – Bradley Wright-Phillips

2011/2012 – Ben Hamer, Johnnie Jackson, Michael Morrison and Rhoys Wiggins

2023/2024 – Alfie May

2024/2025 – Lloyd Jones